1/12/24
Dear Paugh,

This world became a better place 60 years ago today. I have to say you look good for 60, Old Timer (no, not your “pretty good” which in your eyes means pretty bad). Unfortunately for me, I wasn’t able to realize how great you are until around 1998, when my tiny brain started comprehending my existence.
Do you remember returning home from work when Maggie, Ellie and I were little? It was always a party. Maggie and Ellie would mob you with hugs while I climbed onto the back of the couch and catapulted myself into your arms while you said “and there’s Monkey Boy!”
Do you remember how you were always more than willing to go down to the field with all of us to play soccer and/or play Wiffle Ball with me in the backyard? Sometimes, I could tell when you had a hard day. But, all you needed was a few extra minutes before you were ready to hang some curveballs resulting in absolute nukes into the pine trees from your tubby, bowl-cut having, energizer bunny of a son. We would set up situations: bottom of the 8th, down by three. I had to score four runs and then take the mound for the save in the top of the 9th. I can’t tell you how much fun I had doing that, and I have no memory of you saying, “No, Willy. I’m tired, not today.”
Do you remember when I was getting ready to go from “coach-pitch” to regular Little League, and I was being a baby because I was afraid of getting hit by a pitch? You brought Mom’s bucket of 300+ tennis balls with us to the field and threw three buckets full to me as hard as you could from 30 feet away. A third of those pitches either buzzed my tower or absolutely drilled me in the ribs, but it worked like a charm. Soon I was no longer afraid of getting hit by pitch and Little League seemed far less intimidating, although irreversible damage was done to the UCL in your throwing elbow from these sessions.

Do you remember my first Little League game? It was Summer Little League and I was seven years old playing with kids that were in Maggie’s class. The legendary Sharon Little League coach and our friend, Andy Watt, put me in right field in the later innings of a home game down in Sharon Valley. I was scared shitless. But I knew anything that came my way, you and I had practiced it together on that very same field hundreds of times. The first pitch of the inning was a towering pop fly, which seemed to create a shadow right over me. It was my “Scott Smalls” moment from The Sandlot. In my head, I could even hear the ball making the whistling bomb noise as it approached, just like the movie. All the older kids were watching, many having little faith that the seven-year-old right fielder had a chance of catching that high-fly ball. But, when I was looking into the sky and only saw the ball, I forgot about everyone else around me and pretended it was just another fly ball that you had hit. The ball finally made its decent from the heavens and fell into my glove for the first out of the inning. I was more than prepared to make that play thanks to you. Talk about your “Six P’s” am I right? No, you weren’t held back by the boring “Five P’s”, Old Timer, your phrase was far more interesting and memorable. “Prior Planning Prevents Piss Poor Performance” helped me make the play that day as well as thousands of others in my career.

Do you remember – well… who could forget – your son being responsible for the end of the magical Mid-County All-Star run in the district championship game? I hung a 0-2 curveball with two outs and surrendered a game-winning Grand Slam to the talented Wappinger American squad (sorry Jacob Lamb, I cashed in all your runs and blew the save). I cried like a baby the whole ride home from Poughkeepsie to Sharon in your old VW Golf. You reminded me that our team would not have been there without me, that you were proud of me and that you’d love me no matter what. As a twelve year old kid, I couldn’t fathom how someone, let alone my father, could still be proud of me after a colossal failure, but your words helped. Your words led me to ask you the very next day if we could go down to the field and work on pitching when you got home from work. I remember your surprise. You told me after the fact that you were worried my love for baseball would be affected by the events the day before, but when I asked you that you realized – as you’d often say – “we got a live one here!”

Do you remember religiously watching new episodes of Avatar: The Last Airbender the very nights they were released on TV? I miss the old fashion way of watching shows as they aired; in the moment. One of our favorite episodes we watched countless times was the finale of Book One: Water. We learned of the character “Koh”, known as the face stealer, who would steal one’s face upon seeing the slightest facial expression. The spirit of Avatar Roku in the swamp tells Avatar Aang that when he meets Koh he must, “show no fear, show no emotion at all.” You and I used that phrase metaphorically for dealing with the negative things in baseball, especially with pitching. We would throw bullpens together and you reminded me not to have a single reaction to any pitches thrown, whether good or bad. When the session was over, then we could talk about the positives and negatives. It taught me that concentration in the moment requires a steady mind, one not clouded with emotions of any kind. Although, I’ll be the first one to admit I’ll stray away from this from time to time, but more often than not I used this to my advantage. I thank you for that, Avatar Old Timer.

Do you remember my first spring of Team Connecticut Baseball. You and Mama Yahn drove me to practices and games five days a week, whether it was an hour and a half trip to East Hartford or somewhere even further. We would leave at ungodly hours on weekend mornings or we hustled straight from school while I changed and did my homework in the car. Miraculously on your guys’ part, I never missed a practice or a game. There was one morning in particular while we were getting ready to leave for a TCB game I remember very well. I was already awake when you came knocking on my bedroom door, which we both knew was highly unusual. You asked me what was wrong. I proceeded to tell you how the legendary TCB coach, Bob Hetu, scared the ever living piss out of me. In short, Coach Hetu’s tactics could be described as intense to say the least, but he was one of the greatest coaches I ever had in my baseball career. Your response to my fear was spectacular.

“You only ever get hollered at when you make a mistake. So… don’t make any mistakes.” I thought to myself, was it really that easy? But, the more I thought about what you said the more it made sense to me. Going forward, I obsessed over knowing every sign, every pick-off play, bunt defense play, every first and third trick play, I knew every situation like the back of my hand. I recall only one more time all season that I made a mistake and weathered Hetu’s wrath, which was much better than most others on the team. As you often said “your focus determines your reality.”

Do you remember our first Father-Son trip to your hometown of Farmington, Maine? It was the weekend before I started 8th grade in 2009. We visited Uncle Jimmy at his house where he had a dozen deer heads spread all over the walls of the high ceiling, wooden interior living room. We visited Aunt Janet, Uncle Mikey and my cousin Lindsay as well as Grammy Nedra. Then we explored your old stomping grounds including Mount Blue High School, parts of the UM-Farmington campus, Sugarloaf Mountain, the Wire Bridge crossing the Carrabassett River and of course the old Mount Blue Motel that you grew up in and your parents owned for years. Then, we made our way out to East New Portland to visit the grave site of your father and my grandfather, Wallace. It was a surreal moment for me in which I had mixed emotions. My initial reaction was sadness. Selfishly, I thought of the horrifying prospect of not having you in my life. I tried to put myself in your shoes but it was such a scary thought I had to stop. Instead, I thought about the strength you must have had to soldier on in the aftermath of losing your father at 21 years old. I thought about how strong you were as a father and as a man, and even my pee-brained 8th grade self imagined how proud Wally was of you and how happy he was that we stopped by to say hi. If anything he’s only become more proud of you for the great things you’ve done and for the family that you and Ma have created.

Do you remember my first career home at bat as a UConn Husky in 2015? It was a chilly Friday afternoon at J.O. Christian Field which we hoped to use to our advantage against the USF Bulls making the trip from Tampa Bay. Arguably as important as the baseball action, you may recall my Friday walk-up song was Jessica by the Allman Brothers. I know some of my teammates thought it was a strange choice, either because they were surprised this freshman chose such an old song while some had never heard it before, although a few appreciated the selection. Your taste in music inspired me to go in the direction of classic rock for my first walk-up song. So too did your love for guitars as well as your appreciation for the greatest players of all time. The guitar in Jessica is so happy and upbeat that it takes me back to a Saturday morning as a kid running around the house with Maggie and Ellie while Mom made breakfast and you just sat there jamming on one of your guitars happy as a clam. I was mighty proud to have that walk-up song as a testament to you (and of course, a tip of the cap to the Field of Dreams soundtrack as well). My first home hit was that day off of now Big Leaguer Jimmy Herget, who had incredible arm-side run on his fastball coming from a side-arm slot. When I tell you this single was an absolute bleeder into center field off my hands I may be understating the situation. In hindsight, I couldn’t believe it did not hit my top hand. Luckily, my old reliable 2012 hand-me-down Rawlings Velo helped nestle the jam-shot just beyond the outfield grass and between the middle infielders at the cost of every ounce of feeling in my hands on that brisk spring day.

Do you remember the championship game of the American Athletic Conference Tournament in 2016? We were in Clearwater taking on the University of Houston Cougars. In my opinion, the final score of 7-2 did not quite indicate how close of a ballgame it was until our final at bat. After a rain delay prior to the start of the 3rd inning, Anthony Kay went back out there and absolutely shoved while working his way out of some tight jams. Pat Ruotolo was the man who slammed the door shut and suffered the pain of being at the bottom of that glorious dog-pile. With the game still 4-2 in the bottom of the 9th, we wanted to get at least one run if not a few to put Houston away. After Jack Sundberg singled in a run, I came to the plate with runners on the corners and one out. I hacked at the first pitch, very shocking I know, and sent it off the base of the wall in right-center field for a two run triple. After a pitching change, Bobby Melley drove me in with a single up the middle and in the bottom of that inning we secured the only AAC Championship in the program’s history. I recall the first time watching the clip of that triple from the angle of the third-base camera well, showing off my Charlie Hustlesque headfirst slide. Then I paused and was shocked at what I saw in the background… it was YOU, Old Timer! You were doing your stress laps around the concourse with your headphones in while listening to the Voice of the Huskies, Chris Jones, call the game. Your reaction was priceless, your arms were over your head and you were leaning back as you howled to the heavens in joy. Our embrace after the game and trophy presentation was one of the happiest moments of my life.

Do you remember draft day? I know we have talked about this day since and – at least until the actual moment I was drafted – it was a very stressful day to say the least. Not to get into too much detail, but based on things my parents and I had been told from many different sources, we had reason to believe that I was going to be selected earlier than the 25th round in the 2017 MLB Draft. Remember, the first day was only the 1st round and compensatory picks and the second day was the 2nd-10th rounds so once the 20th round came along we were much further into that third day than any of us thought we would be. I received a call from my agent and friend to this day, Derrick Ross, informing us that the Baltimore Orioles were the only team willing to sign me for the dollar amount that you, Ma and I agreed would make it worth going to play professional baseball rather than returning to finish my degree. The really stressful part was that we had no idea when they were going to make the move or if someone else was going to select me first and offer far less. Another Orioles pick passed by and my name was not called. I couldn’t even stand in the room when the Red Sox pick came around, and I got on my knees and prayed when it was the Yankees turn to pick. As it became later in the day, to take the edge off you and I grabbed the only two bottles of cold beer we had in the fridge: Maine Lunch. You played your guitar while we sipped on our Lunch and waited. Not 15 minutes later, I got a call from Derrick and moments after we heard my name called on the draft radio broadcast by the Baltimore Orioles. It must have been the lucky beer from your old stomping grounds, eh Old Timer? A few days later, it was Father’s Day and you took me to the airport to ship me off to professional baseball. We got to the airport early and enjoyed some Dunkin’ before my departure. I remember we didn’t say a ton, I think we were both in a state of excitement and slight shock that this was actually happening. We finished our coffee and embraced one more time on that memorable Father’s Day.

Do you remember when I got called up to AA and Bowie was scheduled to play in Hartford? The night before was the 2019 Carolina League All-Star game, proudly hosted by our then High-A affiliate Frederick Keys. You and Ma made the trip to Western Maryland for the All-Star game only to chauffeur me all the way back to Hartford early the very next morning. You guys dropped me off at the team hotel in Newington and went home to recuperate. Amazingly, you both hightailed it back to Hartford for my AA debut that night at Dunkin’ Donuts Park. I hit a double in my first at bat and made a few solid plays at third, but towards the end of the game I just wanted to see you and Ma and thank you guys for having helped me reach that point in my career.
Do you remember when you came to Norfolk, Virginia when I got called up to AAA for the second time that season? Oh what a beautifully confusing mess that 2021 season was, eh Old Timer? One of the best moments of the season, though, was when you came to the first game after I got called back up because, “I’m not gonna miss my chance to see my son in AAA this time, damnit!” They must have known you were coming because they decided to start me at shortstop that day. I wouldn’t say it was the most dazzling overall performance out of me in my career, but all I wanted was a knock for you. Sure enough, out of my four chances at the plate I managed one hard barrel through the left side for a base hit. Obviously, I would ideally like to go 4 for 4 with 4 home runs, wouldn’t we all? But being able to at least get a knock for you and have a positive moment from the AAA game you traveled all that way for was incredibly special.

Do you remember when I joined you in the Old Timer rankings when I became an Uncle and you became Grandpa Walt? It was a glorious day in the family’s history as Maggie, with brother Hector by her side, brought beautiful Mia Umaña into the world this past Fourth of July. I remember the first time I saw you and Ma hold little Mia as grandparents and seeing Maggie holding her as her mother, my brain could not compute the situation. It was such a beautiful and indescribable feeling of having an addition to the family to love and cherish forever. It all started with you and Ma, Old Timer. You guys paved the road to this tight-knit and loving family dynamic we have with our immediate family. It’s not perfect, as we know nothing in this mortal world is, but it is beautiful and unique and we all appreciate it because it’s not always the case with every family.
Thank you for being the man that you are and helping me become the man that I am today. You are and have always been my hero, I mean that with all my heart, Old Timer. Happy birthday, Paugh.
With Love,
Willy
*This was written the days leading up to my father’s 60th and I presented the story to him the night of his birthday. I wanted him to read the rough draft first before making all of the corrections and adding the multimedia and publishing for all to read. More content coming soon! -Willy*

































After an Erie Seawolves loss late in the schedule, we finally clinched the Western Division while in Richmond, Virginia, and we were playoff bound. It was my first time making the playoffs in professional baseball and it was electric. The Baysox bought us 270 beers and 40 champagne bottles to pop and spray all over each other and drink as much or as little as you want, it was an absolute blast. Raging like that with the boys, and having videos of us posted everywhere doing so, was really weird. But it’s just what you do in professional baseball when you win. It is probably the only time in any of our lives when we can be drunk and rowdy and have 